Mailing list [arc-dev]: Archives

Re: [arc-dev] RDF statements don't have identifiers

From: "Patrick Gosetti-Murray-John" 
Subject: Re: [arc-dev] RDF statements don't have identifiers
Date: Sat, 17 May 2008 07:24:35 -0400


Is there a handy way to reify the statements and work that way?

Patrick

>>> Eric Hanson <elh@cs.pdx.edu> 05/17/08 4:02 AM >>>


Olivier GENDRIN wrote:
>=20
>> Here's the problem:  As far as I can tell, it's not possible=20
>> to make statements about statements, because RDF statements=20
>> don't have identifiers.  As such, it's impossible to do a=20
>> whole host of things that I believe are essential to any=20
>> web-scale data platform:
>=20
> You can give them identifier. If in a database, a statment would have an
> statement_id...

In ARC's internal structure (for example) statements do have internal=20
IDs.  However, these IDs aren't URIs, they're the relational IDs of the=20
backend MySQL store, so they can't be used to describe the statement.

This of course isn't a weakness of ARC, it's just the way RDF works.

Eric